Hindu Doctrine Of Karma: A Plausible Versus Rationally Defensible Explanation And/or Justification For Human Suffering

  • Words 1558
  • Pages 3
Download PDF

Describe the Hindu doctrine of karma and discuss whether or not you think it offers a plausible or rationally defensible explanation and/or justification for human suffering.

The doctrine of karma, as elaborated by Hinduism, gives a powerous explanatory account of the human difficulty and particularly of the apparently unreserved human suffering such as children’s suffering, the occurrence of natural disasters, and the chance of universal salvation. Karma is an important concept of Hinduism, meaning action. Belief in karma is deeply embedded in the minds of Hindus, according to which activities according to their nature will have implications. In this essay, we present on the spiritual path the notion of karma, its origin, significance, and the resolution of karma. The karma theory appears initially at least, much more satisfactory than the attempts made to solve the perennial problem of evil by writers working with the mainstream theistic traditions. Firstly, I will contend what the doctrine of karma means in Hinduism. Secondly, if it offers a reasonable justification for human suffering.

Karma doctrine not only as a theodicy, but also as a theory in the sense of a fully formed philosophical account of the presence of evil or known as the full systemic theory of human suffering’s origins and explanations. Karma is not meant to be a record of evil’s origins. Karma theorist does not allow the cycle of birth and rebirth to begin at all, however the theory of karma is not generally presented by its advocates as a full and systematic explanation of human suffering. Rather, the theorist of karma wants to represent our ignorance in the face of the complexity of reality by providing only a rough account of why people suffer. The theory of karma does not allow past lives to be remembered and therefore errors made in past lives. Realising previous errors is by no means an essential or even the most significant educational force in our life.

Click to get a unique essay

Our writers can write you a new plagiarism-free essay on any topic

The theory of karma and rebirth explains that the root cause of human suffering is lust and attachment to the fruits of one action. The agent cannot advance on the road to liberty as long as these wishes and attachments persist in the agent. The concept of karma is set forth as an explanation for human pain as a week as a guide to how we can overcome our sufferings. The doctrine of karma therefore presupposes the capacity for moral development and details how we can accomplish it. Kaufman suggests that the concept of karma can morally fix the problem of evil only if it presupposes a proportional principle, namely the severity of the wrong.’ The doctrine of karma as a solution to the problem of suffering is unsatisfactory ( Perrett roy). The value of the doctrine of karma as a solution to the issue of misery has often been embraced in India and the West. One of the factors Indians think in karma and reincarnation is that many elements of human existence, including human birth inequalities (Hick J), make sense of the hypothesis. Hick describes that there is either a first life marked by original human variations or, if incarnations, there is no first life but a start less regress. The karma doctrine describes my current condition by referring to my past life’s casual influences. It is also admitted that before that and so on, my prior life situation should be clarified by reference to my life. It also thought that the Indians thought that this cycle of rebirths started less and there was an infinite regression here. While an individual instances of suffering are explicable by reference to the karma, the fact that suffering exists in our world at all is just a brute fact about our world. Explanation has to come to an end somewhere their have to be some brute facts. The counter claim suffering is thus ultimately unintelligible is just an emotionally coloured response to the inevitable way that explanatory chains terminate. The ultimate explanation that is being asked fir just doesn’t exist and to persists in demanding it is just to misunderstand the nature of explanation. This can be also highlighted by consideration of a possible attempt to provide such an ultimate explanation. Suppose we explain the existence of suffering in relation to gods purpose, we espouse in other words some sort of soul making theodicy such that the existence of the contingent fact of suffering of suffering is explained by reference to its being required by gods plans for us to develop morally as free persons , evolving eventually into children’s of god (Hick J).

Hindus believe that thought is capable of creating things and impacting others. Harmful ideas aimed at others have the capacity not only to harm others, but also the individual who unleashed them. Since ancient Hindus used mantras for everything and the mantras had great power and power to make or break things, it became necessary to practice yoga to stabilize the minds and thoughts of those who had mantras knowledge and the ability to use them effectively. Ancient rishis had the authority through their power of thought to materialize stuff.

A person’s karma caused by his actions determines the course of his life on earth and his progress to the greater worlds. Because karma is a mechanism to correct and regulate, our activities have the ability to mitigate or intensify our suffering. The purpose of Karma is to teach us lessons. We will make progress towards perfection if we learn rapidly. If not, until we recognize our errors and correct them, we will be provided with much harder alternatives. Good deeds lead to inner peace and happiness, while bad deeds have negative effects on ourselves and our dependent souls.

Karma and reincarnation are two significant principles of Hinduism that guide one’s activities and impact pain. In essence, reincarnation means being born again. The body is like a collection of clothes removed by the soul before placing on fresh clothes. One can be born as a human, an animal, an insect, or even a plant from an Hindu point of view. What the next incarnation takes depends on karma, and the hierarchy can be moved up or down. They are born into a happier existence if a person has lived a good life and performed more good deeds than bad. Karma guides how a Hindu lives, and the actions of each person in current and past lives determine what kind of regeneration they achieve. Karma is a combination of cosmic and moral cause and effect that crosses the lessons learned for spiritual growth in life and life. There are three kinds of karma: past-life karma that may or may not be experienced in the current lifetime, present-day karma being produced, and future karma or karmic experiences saved for the future. A devout Hindu is going to be non-violent at all levels, including vegetarianism practice. After many lifetimes, the ultimate goal is to be released from rebirth or to attain moksha; to become one with Brahman. Mental and physical suffering is believed to be component of the unfolding of karma and is the result of previous inappropriate action (mental, verbal, or physical) occurring either in one’s present life or in a past life. It is not seen as penalty, but in reaction to previous adverse conduct as a natural result of the universe’s moral legislation. By embracing it as a just result and understanding that suffering is not random, Hindu traditions encourage coping with pain. Experiencing present pain also satisfies past adverse behaviour’s debt. Suffering is seen as part of life until moksha is lastly reached. Until this state is reached, there is always suffering on the road of life. Because we are in human form on earth, Hindu tradition maintains that we are bound by the legislation of our globe and will experience physical pain. Pain is truly felt in our current physical bodies.

Suffering for the Hindu is closely related to the concept of karma. Hindu spiritual suffering comes from knowing at the end of life that responsibilities and tasks are left uncompleted or bad thoughts and deeds had prevailed. Karma conveys that suffering is a part of life. Suffering is a result of past thoughts and actions either in this life or the previous life. Exactly like karma, when someone endures suffering, they ultimately “pay for” their past negative actions. Hindus have been pretty happy with that explanation for thousands of years. So it must make perfect sense to them. Every action has an equal and opposite reaction.

  1. Kaufman R. P, W 2005, karma, rebirth, and the problem of evil, University of HAWAII PRESS, retrieved 19 August 2019 URL > https://www-jstor-org.ezproxy-b.deakin.edu.au/stable/pdf/4487934.pdf?refreqid=excelsior%3A533d926a5bc93f3434c9d25ff8320a1b
  2. Kaufman R. P, W 2007, Karma and the problem of evil: a response to Kaufman, University of HAWAII PRESS, retrieved 19 August 2019 URL > https://www-jstor-org.ezproxy-b.deakin.edu.au/stable/pdf/20109427.pdf?refreqid=excelsior%3A200a98718b6f99a88bf0f1c367e7b695
  3. Link-springer-com.ezproxy-b.deakin.edu.au. (2019). Shibboleth Authentication Request. [online] retrieved 19 August 2019, Available at: https://link-springer-com.ezproxy-b.deakin.edu.au/content/pdf/10.1007%2FBF02910603.pdf
  4. Kaufman R. P, W 2007, Karma, rebirth and the problem of evil: a reply to critics, University of HAWAII PRESS, retrieved 19 August 2019, URL > https://www-jstor-org.ezproxy-b.deakin.edu.au/stable/pdf/20109428.pdf?refreqid=excelsior%3Ac26dfe14739bf16b767d9769f0175e7c
  5. Content.talisaspire.com. (2019). Login to access resource. [online] retrieved 20 August 2019, Available at: https://content.talisaspire.com/deakin/bundles/59caf5bb646be024217d6514
  6. Hinduwebsite.com. (2019). The Concept Of Karma In Hinduism. [online], retrieved 20 August 2019, URL Available at: https://www.hinduwebsite.com/conceptofkarma.asp
  7. Uphs.upenn.edu. (2019). [online], retrieved 20 August 2019, URL, Available at: http://www.uphs.upenn.edu/pastoral/events/Hindu_painsuffering.pdf
  8. The Odyssey Online. (2016). Hinduism And Suffering: A Way of Life., [online], retrieved 20 August 2019, URL, Available at: https://www.theodysseyonline.com/hinduism-and-suffering-way-of-life


We use cookies to give you the best experience possible. By continuing we’ll assume you board with our cookie policy.